My Neighbor’s Tree Fell on My House. Their Insurance Has to Pay for It…Right? by Meagan Beaverson
Wrong. But only maybe.
It seems pretty simple. Your neighbor owns the tree. Their tree falls on your house. Their insurance should pay for it, right? Not necessarily.
When it comes to fallen trees and insurance, ownership doesn’t always determine who pays. How and why the tree came down matters, too. Say a windstorm rolls through and takes down an otherwise healthy tree in your neighbor’s yard. It just happens to land on your house. In most cases, you’ll turn to your homeowners insurance for the damage, subject to your policy coverage and deductible. Your neighbor isn’t automatically responsible just because it was their tree.
So where does the “maybe” come in?
What if the tree was dead? Maybe it had been rotting for years, had large dead limbs hanging over your house, or was leaning a little more in your direction every time you looked at it. Maybe you had even mentioned it to your neighbor before.
That can change things.
If your neighbor knew, or reasonably should have known, the tree was a hazard and did nothing about it, you could have a negligence claim. That’s when their liability coverage may come into play.
If you’ve been staring at your neighbor’s half-dead tree for the last two years, wondering when it’ll finally come down, now is probably the time to say something. If you’re truly concerned, put it in writing and take a few pictures. Hopefully, you’ll never need them.
A couple of other tree-related insurance surprises are worth knowing, too.
If a storm knocks a tree over and it lands in the middle of your yard without damaging anything, don’t assume your homeowners policy will pay to haul it away. Some policies cover tree and debris removal in certain situations, but what applies and how much is available depends on your policy.
And what if the tree misses your house but lands on your car instead? Now we’re talking about your auto insurance. Damage from a falling tree generally falls under comprehensive coverage, if you carry it.
Remember, insurance is rarely as simple as “your tree, your problem.” The cause of the damage, what was damaged, the tree’s condition, and the coverage you carry can all affect how a claim is handled.
So, as we head into another Northwest Ohio winter filled with wind, ice, snow, and whatever else Mother Nature decides to throw at us, take a look around your property. If you see a tree that concerns you, whether it’s yours or your neighbor’s, now is a good time to address it.
It’s much easier to have that conversation while the tree is still standing.
Megan Beaverson | LeGalley Insurance Agency,
LLC | 419-353-0405